Purpose of Olympic Scoring is to . . .
. . . extract some consensually validated new product, process, or other innovative ideas or concepts while encouraging 100 percent participation. The following is particularly appropriate when facilitating olympic scoring with larger groups of nine or more participants.
Background of Olympic Scoring
In advance, inform all of your participants to bring at least one idea or response to a prepared question that will be addressed during the meeting or workshop. While focused on a central theme (eg, solution to a problem), break down your primary question into small, manageable pieces.
For example, do NOT ask what does the Marketing Plan look like? Understand that “Y” is a function of numerous large “X” and small “x” so ask solid, detailed questions such as: Who should be our target audience for _________? What should the message for for target audience _____________ ?
Methodology of Olympic Scoring
Build three sets of flash cards with the numbers one through ten on each set. Consider using 4in * 6in index cards. In the meeting or workshop, consciously or randomly select three class members (“experts”) who will serve as judges rather than content providers.
After meeting participants present each idea or concept, the judges flash their scores, with more being better (ie, ten is the best). The facilitator captures the three scores and tabulates them on a large Post-It®. The highest score does not necessarily win, but discussion will be minimized, if not eliminated, around the low scoring options, thus encouraging the group to focus its discussion around the best candidates.
Deliverable from Olympic Scoring
Subsequently or concurrently the facilitator leads discussions about the reason(s) to support the higher scores and captures the reasons and rationale for their decision on large Post-Its. The reasons provide the criteria that can now be used to re-evaluate all the ideas, or to create new ideas, that optimally satisfy the appropriate criteria.
Considerations when Olympic Scoring
Consider prioritizing or weighting the criteria since some will be more important than others. Traditionally the weighting system runs from one to five where more is better. You might use the Scorecard tool to calculate detailed scores or consider using the Perceptual Map tool and arraying your options against the most important criteria.
If you have your participants prepare responses to more than one question, and have additional time, start over again. Consider appointing new judges so that all voices are viewed as equal contributors.
Become Part of the Solution—Improve Your Facilitation and Methodology Skills
To help you access our in-house resources, (e.g., annotated agendas and templates used in our FAST Professional Facilitation Training) go to the Facilitation Training Store https://mgrush.com/shop/. For a nominal fee, you can now access some our favorite tools, including:
▪ First of all, highly effective PPT Break Timers for $19.99
▪ Quick, five to ten-minute video lessons on critical topics for $29.99
▪ White papers with additional methodology and team-based meeting support for only $9.99
▪ Holarchy Poster for conference rooms to help resolve arguments
Purchase the book “Change or Die, a Business Process Improvement Manual” for much of the support you might need to lead more effective groups, teams, and meetings.
Furthermore, the FAST curriculum on Professional Facilitation Skills details the responsibilities and dynamics of an effective facilitator and methodologist. Remember, nobody is smarter than everybody, so consult your FAST Facilitator Reference Manual. Or, attend a FAST professional facilitative leadership-training workshop offered around the world (see MG Rush for a current schedule — an excellent way to earn 40 PDUs from PMI, CDUs from IIBA, or CEUs).
Finally, do not forget to order Change or Die if you’re working on a business process improvement project. It provides detailed workshop agendas and numerous tools to make your role easier and your team’s performance a lot more effective—daring you to embrace the will, wisdom, and activities that amplify a facilitative leader.